空间正义视角下南京街头艺人时空分布特征与规划策略
Spatial-Justice Perspective of Nanjing Busker’s Characteristic about Time & Space Distribution and Planning Strategy
张 鹏
东南大学建筑学院 博士研究生
蒲 卉
新疆城乡规划设计研究院有限公司 助理工程师
摘要: 在我国城市化加速推进的过程中，城市空间正义的缺失问题日益突出，街头卖艺便是其中一个具有代表性的案例。探讨了街头艺人的内涵及研究意义，从“作为城市问题”和“作为城市景观”两条线索的逻辑困境展开，并以空间正义的视角进行思辨。通过调查与问卷调查结合的方法，对南京市街头艺人的类型构成、行为活动特征、空间分布特征、公众接受程度等方面进行了数据分析，认为城市管理者和规划者应当重视街头艺人的生存发展和卖艺行为的规范化问题，并从空间规划、城市管理以及艺人自身角度等方面分别提出了规划策略。
Abstract: In the process of accelerating urbanization in our country, the lack of urban space justice is increasingly prominent, and busking is one of the typical cases. This article first discusses the connotation and research significance of busker, from the logic dilemma of two clues, ‘as the city problem’ and ‘as the city landscape ’, and then from the angle of spatial justice. Through the investigation and questionnaire survey method, this paper analyzes the type of Nanjing buskers, their activity characteristics, spatial distribution characteristics, and degree of public acceptance, and proposes that the city managers and planners should pay great attention to the existence, development and standardization of the busker behavior problems. It puts forward the planning strategy from the perspective of spatial planning, urban management and artists themselves respectively.
关键词：空间正义、南京街头艺人、分布特征、规划策略
Keyword: Spatial justice，Buskers in Nanjing，Distribution characteristics，Planning strategy
中图分类号：TU981
文献标识码: A
[1]任远，彭希哲．2006中国非正规就业发展报告：劳动力市场的再观察[M]．重庆：重庆出版社，2007．
REN Yuan, PENG Xizhe. Informal employment in China development report 2006: to observe the labor market[M]．Chongqing: Chongqing Press, 2007.
[2]魏春雨，王丰. 摊贩•城市[J]. 华中建筑，2008（5）：106-108．WEI Chunyu, WANG Feng. Street vendors•City[J]. Huazhong architecture, 2008(5): 106—108．
[3]张玉鑫，奚东帆. 聚焦公共空间艺术，提升城市软实力——关于上海城市公共空间规划与建设的思考[J]. 上海城市规划，2013（6）：23-27.
ZHANG Yuxin, XI Dongfan. Focus on public space art, promote urban soft power: thinking about the planning and construction of Shanghai urban public space[J]. Shanghai Urban Planning, 2013(6): 23-27.
[4]许云飞. 建构城市特色的途径：艺术介入下的空间规划[J]. 规划师，2016（8）：18-21.
XU Yunfei. Construction of city characteristic ways: art under the intervention of space planning[J]. Planners, 2016(8): 18-21.
[5]邱冰，张帆. 基于城市集体记忆建构的城市公共艺术规划——一种公共艺术介入环境空间规划设计的路径[J]. 规划师，2016（8）：12-17.
QIU Bing, ZHANG Fan. Based on the urban construction of urban public art planning of collective memory: a kind of public art in the environment space planning and design path[J]. Planners, 2016(8): 12-17.
[6]赵容慧，曾辉，卓想. 艺术介入策略下的新农村社区营造——台湾台南市土沟社区的营造[J]. 规划师，2016（2）：109-115.
ZHAO Ronghui, ZENG Hui, ZHUO Xiang. Art intervention strategies under the new rural community construction earth ditch, Taiwan Tainan city community construction[J]. Planners, 2016(2): 109-115.
[7]刘雨菡，张珊珊，鲍梓婷. 艺术介入的社区营造与规划思考[J]. 规划师，2016（8）：29-34.
LIU Yuhan, ZHANG Shanshan, BAO Ziting. Art involvement in community construction and planning of thinking[J]. Planners, 2016(8): 29-34.
[8]陈锐，钱慧，王红扬. 治理结构视角的艺术介入型乡村复兴机制——基于日本濑户内海艺术祭的实证观察[J]. 规划师，2016（8）：35-39.
CHEN Rui, QIAN Hui, WANG Hongyang. Governance structure point of view of art intervenes model village renewal mechanism: based on empirical observation of the seto island sea of Japan art offering[J]. Planners, 2016(8): 35-39.
[9]陈径舟，黄思宇. 街头艺人也应受到尊重[N]. 中国文化报，2015-04-22.
CHEN Jingzhou,HUANG Siyu.Street performers should be respected[N]. Chinese Culture Newspaper, 2015-04-22.
[10]林晓芸. 街头艺人：渴望发出草根文化之音[N]. 文化月刊，2012-12-15.
LIN Xiaoyun. Buskers: eager to voice of the grassroots[N]. Cultural Issue, 2012-12-15.
[11]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Main_Page.
[12]陈映芳. 城市开发的正当性危机与合理性空间[J]. 社会学研究，2008（3）：29-55．CHEN Yingfang. The legitimacy crisis and the rationality of the urban development space[J]. Sociological Study, 2008(3): 29-55．
[13]傅盛裕，俞丽虹. 街头艺人能否成为“城市景观”? 可能得双向提高[N]. 新华每日电讯，2008-05-08．
FU Shengyu, YU Lihong. A busker can become ‘urban landscape’? may require two aspects to improve[N]. Xinhua Daily Telegraph, 2008-05-08．
[14]陈浩，张京祥，吴启焰. 转型期城市空间再开发中非均衡博弈的透视——政治经济学的视角[J]. 城市规划学刊，2010（5）：33-40.
CHEN Hao, ZHANG Jingxiang, WU Qiyan. The imbalance of powers and politics: political economy in urban redevelopment projects during the period of institutional transition[J]. Urban Planning Forum, 2010(5): 33-40.
[15]LEFEBVRE H. The production of space[M]. Donald Nicholson-Smith, translate. Oxford: Blackwell LTD, 1991: 26.
[16]福柯. 空间、知识、权力：后现代性与地理学的政治[M]. 上海：上海教育出版社，2001.
FOUCAULT M. After the space, knowledge and power: modernity and the political geography[M]. Shanghai Education Press, 2001.
[17]张京祥，陈浩. 中国的压缩城市化环境与规划应对[J]． 城市规划学刊，2010 （6）：10-21．
ZHANG Jingxiang, CHEN Hao. China’s compressed urbanization and urban planning responses [J]．Urban Planning Forum, 2010 (6)：10-21．
[18]曹现强，张福磊. 我国城市空间正义缺失的逻辑及其矫治[J]．城市发展研究，2012（3）：5-9.
CAO Xianqiang, ZHANG Fulei. The logic of the lack of justice in China’s urban space and the correction of spatial injustice[J]．Urban Development Research, 2012(3): 5-9.
[19]曹现强，张福磊. 空间正义：形成、内涵及意义[J]. 城市发展研究，2011（4）：1-5.
CAO Xianqiang, ZHANG Fulei. Spatial justice: context, development and connotation[J]．Urban Development Research, 2011(4): 1-5.
[20]包蹇. 街头艺人如何用“法”管[N]. 人民日报，2012-12-14．
BAO Jian. Buskers how to use the management law [N ]. The People's Daily，2012-12-14．
[21]YANG Y, CHANG C. An urban regeneration regime in China: a case study of urban redevelopment in Shanghai's Taipingqiao area[J]. Urban Studies, 2007(9): 1809-1826.
[22]LEFEBVRE H. Space and politics[M]. LI Chun, translate. Shanghai: Shanghai People's Press, 2008: 21-62.
