组织模式视角下的在地性社区规划探索* ——以武汉市登月小区为例
Exploration of Local Community Planning from the Perspective of Organi-zational Model: A Case Study of Dengyue Community in Wuhan
胡洲伟
武汉大学城市设计学院 博士研究生
郭 炎（通信作者
武汉大学城市设计学院 副教授
摘要: 社区规划已成为提升基层社会治理能力的前沿阵地。然而，长期自上而下、重物质空间轻社会发展的建设模式，导致社区内部集体行动能力低下、对外话语权薄弱，社区可持续发展缺乏内生动力。需要衔接社区内部和对外的互动协作，重建在地性社区规划的组织模式。现有相关研究多采用“政府—市场—社会”的三元框架，缺乏层次性。基于集体行动理论和沟通规划理论，从群内多主体横向联动、群际多层级纵向协作两个层面入手，建立社区规划组织模式的多主体—多层级分析框架。结合湖北省武汉市登月小区的社区规划实践，应用该框架解释社区规划参与主体的阶段性互动关系，建议因地制宜构建社区规划组织模式。
Abstract: Community planning has become the forefront of social governance. However, the long-term top-down construction mode, emphasizing the built environment while ignoring social development, leads to the low collective action capacity and the weak discourse power of the community. It is necessary to facilitate the interaction and collaboration between communities inside and outside and rebuild the organizational model of the local community planning. The existing relevant studies mostly adopt the ternary framework of "government, market and society", which lacks hierarchy. Based on the theory of collective action and communication planning, this paper establishes a multi-agent & multi-level analytical framework for the community planning organizational model from two aspects: the horizontal linkage of multi-agents within the group and the vertical collaboration of multi-levels among the groups. Based on the practice of Dengyue Community, this paper applies the framework to explain the periodic interaction between the participants of community planning, and suggests that the organization model of community planning should be constructed according to local conditions.
关键词：在地性;社区规划;居民参与
Keyword: localization; community planning; public participation
中图分类号：TU984
文献标识码: A
资金资助
国家自然科学基金项目 “资本循环视角下乡村社会空间重构的机理、效应与调适——以湖北湖南两个县级行政区为例” 41971185
杨保军，陈鹏. 社会冲突理论视角下的规划变革[J]. 城市规划学刊，2015（1）：24-31.
YANG Baojun, CHEN Peng. Planning reform from the perspective of social conflict theories[J]. Urban Planning Forum, 2015(1): 24-31.
赵民. “社区营造”与城市规划的“社区指向”研究[J]. 规划师，2013，29（9）：5-10.
ZHAO Min. A discussion on community building and community preference in city planning[J]. Planners, 2013, 29(9): 5-10.
TONNIES F. Community and society[M]. New Brunswick/London: Transaction Publishers, 2004.
栾晓帆，刘一鸣，李志刚. 应对突发公共事件的社区建设策略——基于“社区”概念的辨析[J]. 规划师，2020，36（6）：116-120.
LUAN Xiaofan, LIU Yiming, LI Zhigang. Resilient community construction in response to public emergencies: based on the analysis of the concept of "community"[J]. Planners, 2020, 36(6): 116-120.
费孝通. 居民自治：中国城市社区建设的新目标[J]. 江海学刊，2002（3）：15-18.
FEI Xiaotong. Autonomy of resident: new target of community construction in urban China[J]. Jianghai Academic Journal, 2002(3): 15-18.
赵民，赵蔚. 关注城市规划的社会性——兼论城市社区发展规划[J]. 上海城市规划，2006（6）：8-11.
ZHAO Min, ZHAO Wei. On social urban planning—an introduction to urban community development planning[J]. Shanghai Urban Planning Review, 2006(6): 8-11.
钱征寒，牛慧恩. 社区规划——理论、实践及其在我国的推广建议[J]. 城市规划学刊，2007（4）：74-78.
QIAN Zhenghan, NIU Enhui. Community planning—theory, practice and suggestion on its popularization in China[J]. Urban Planning Forum, 2007(4): 74-78.
杨贵庆，房佳琳，何江夏. 改革开放40年社区规划的兴起和发展[J]. 城市规划学刊，2018（6）：29-36.
YANG Guiqing, FANG Jialin, HE Jiangxia. The rise and development of China's community planning in the past 40 years since the reform and open up[J]. Urban Planning Forum, 2018(6): 29-36.
HARVEY D. The urban experience[M]. Baltimore: The Johns Hopkins University Press, 1985.
威廉•洛尔. 从地方到全球：美国社区规划100年[J]. 张纯，译. 国际城市规划，2011，26（2）：85-98.
ROHE W M. From local to global: one hundred years of neighborhood planning[J]. ZHANG Chun, translate. Urban Planning International, 2011, 26(2): 85-98.
曹康，王晖. 从工具理性到交往理性——现代城市规划思想内核与理论的变迁[J]. 城市规划，2009，33（9）：44-51.
CAO Kang, WANG Hui. From instrumental rationality to communicative rationality: a shift of thoughts and theories of modern urban planning[J]. City Planning Review, 2009, 33(9): 44-51.
王丰龙，陈倩敏，许艳艳，等. 沟通式规划理论的简介，批判与借鉴[J]. 国际城市规划，2012，27（6）：82-90.
WANG Fenglong, CHEN Qianmin, XU Yanyan, et al. Communicative planning theory: introduction, criticism and inspiration[J]. Urban Planning International, 2012, 27(6): 82-90.
胡伟. 城市规划与社区规划之辨析[J]. 城市规划汇刊，2001（1）：60-63.
HU Wei. Urban planning and community planning[J]. Urban Planning Forum, 2001(1): 60-63.
袁媛，柳叶，林静. 国外社区规划近十五年研究进展——基于Citespace软件的可视化分析[J]. 上海城市规划，2015（4）：26-33.
YUAN Yuan, LIU Ye, LIN Jing. Review on community planning research of foreign countries in the past 15 years: a visualized analysis based on citespace software[J]. Shanghai Urban Planning Review, 2015(4): 26-33.
薛德升，曹丰林. 中国社区规划研究初探[J]. 规划师，2013，20（5）：90-92.
XUE Desheng, CAO Fenglin. Elementary study on the community planning in China[J]. Planners, 2013, 20(5): 90-92.
袁媛，陈金城. 低收入社区的规划协作机制研究——以广州市同德街规划为例[J]. 城市规划学刊，2015（1）：46-53.
YUAN Yuan, CHEN Jincheng. The collaborative mechanism in urban planning of low-income community—a case study of regulatory plan of Tongdejie of Guangzhou[J]. Urban Planning Forum, 2015(1): 46-53.
刘佳燕，谈小燕，程情仪. 转型背景下参与式社区规划的实践和思考——以北京市清河街道Y社区为例[J]. 上海城市规划，2017（2）：23-28.
LIU Jiayan, TAN Xiaoyan, CHENG Qingyi. Practice and reflection of participatory community planning under the background of transformation: a case study of Y Community, Qinghe District in Beijing[J]. Shanghai Urban Planning Review, 2017(2): 23-28.
李郇，刘敏，黄耀福. 社区参与的新模式——以厦门曾厝垵共同缔造工作坊为例[J]. 城市规划，2018，42（9）：39-44.
LI Xun, LIU Min, HUANG Yaofu. A new model of community participation: a case study of "jointly development" workshop in Zengcuo'an, Xiamen[J]. City Planning Review, 2018, 42(9): 39-44.
黄怡，吴长福. 基于城市更新与治理的我国社区规划探析——以上海浦东新区金杨新村街道社区规划为例[J]. 城市发展研究，2020，27（4）：110-118.
HUANG Yi, WU Changfu. Exploration on China's community planning based on urban regeneration and urban governance: practice of Jinyang New Village Community in Pudong New Area of Shanghai[J]. Urban Development Studies, 2020, 27(4): 110-118.
FLYVBJERG B. Rationality and power: democracy in practice[M]. Chicago: The University of Chicago Press, 1998.
MCGUIRK P M. Situating communicative planning theory: context, power, and knowledge[J]. Environment and Planning A: Economy and Space, 2001, 33(2): 195-217.
MÄNTYSALO R. Dilemmas in critical planning theory[J]. The Town Planning Review, 2002, 73(4): 417-436.
HUXLEY M. The limits to communicative planning[J]. Journal of Planning Education and Research, 2000, 19(4): 369-377.
SAMUELSON P A. The pure theory of public expenditure[J]. The Review of Economics and Statistics, 1954, 36(4): 387-389.
OSTROM E, GARDNER R, WALKER J. Rules, games, and common-pool resources[M]. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press, 1994.
HARDIN G. The tragedy of the commons[J]. Science, 1968, 162(3859): 1243-1248.
OLSON M. The logic of collective action: public goods and the theory of groups[M]. Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 1965.
OSTROM E. Reformulating the commons[J]. Swiss Political Science Review, 2002, 6(1): 29-52.
OSTROM E. Multiple institutions for multiple outcomes[M]. London: Earthscan, 2007.
刘达，郭炎，祝莹，等. 集体行动视角下的社区规划辨析与实践[J]. 规划师，2018（2）：42-47.
LIU Da, GUO Yan, ZHU Ying, et al. Analysis and practice of community planning based on collective action[J]. Planners, 2018(2): 42-47.
TAYLOR N. Urban planning theory since 1945[M]. London: Sage Publications, 1998.
帕齐•希利. 通过辩论做规划：规划理论中的交往转向[J]. 国际城市规划，2009，24（z1）：339-349.
HEALEY P. Planning through debate: the communicative turn in planning theory[J]. Urban Planning International, 2009, 24(z1): 339-349.
HABERMAS J. The theory of communicative action: reason and the rationalization of society, volume 1[J]. Philosophical Review, 1986, 95(2): 269-272.
FORESTER J. Critical theory and planning practice[J]. Journal of the American Planning Association, 1980, 46(3): 275-286.
FORESTER J. Planning in the face of power[M]. Berkeley: University of California Press, 1989.
INNES J E. Information in communicative planning[J]. Journal of the American Planning Association, 1998, 64(1): 52-63.
姜梅，姜涛. “规划中的沟通”与“作为沟通的规划”：当代西方沟通规划理论概述[J]. 城市规划学刊，2008（2）：31-38.
JIANG Mei, JIANG Tao. "Communication in planning" and "communication as planning": a review on the contemporary western communicative planning theory[J]. Urban Planning Forum, 2008(2): 31-38.
ANTHONY G. The constitution of society[M]. Berkeley: University of California Press, 1986.
FAINSTEIN S S. New directions in planning theory[J]. Urban Affairs Review, 2000, 35(4): 451-478.
